Skip to content

docs: vet all ten official Product Design plugin candidates without admission - #561

Merged
Knapp-Kevin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
curation/openai-product-design-ten-vetting-20261031-no-ci
Nov 1, 2026
Merged

Knapp-Kevin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
curation/openai-product-design-ten-vetting-20261031-no-ci

Conversation

@Knapp-Kevin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Closes #560 after merge.

Macro-first bounded source vetting

  • Official registered openai/plugins observed revision 0722921d5542fc593105c27bd52630babd8b8c2a, proprietary product-design plugin v0.1.52.
  • Exact finite candidate denominator: 10/10 first-class skills, individual Git blob + package tree identity, per-skill utility rationale, dependencies, authority/privacy/portability, trigger boundaries and explicit not-run security/behavioral states.
  • 2 REFERENCE-ONLY / 8 REJECT unchanged, 0 admissions, 0 new semantic review pairs, 0 source pin changes, 0 admitted denominator delta.
  • Macro findings: automatic private context preflight and ImageGen disclosure, unscoped private connector reads, live browser interaction, source-asset copying without rights, local dependency/project writes and deployment/visibility/cost authorization. Useful source-vs-rendered design QA and visual-selection methods preserved as reference.
  • 6 passive files: dated review plus README, SYSTEM_STATE, CURATION_QUEUE, INDEX, index.json. Counts 44 / 995 / 1039, registered sources 23, pinned corpora 12, unchanged.
  • No source code, third-party files, scripts, runtime, CI, scanner, scheduler, deployment, or test execution added. All upstream tools are source-owned reference material.

Lifecycle gate

Five pre-existing drafts #489/#492/#496/#412/#413 are qualification-held, not made merge-ready by this review. No other concurrent lane touched. Review issue #560 can close after this PR merges.

Verification

Single commit 7350818cb56f83891faa6ebaf0d7bf49406668de based on main 19856e29b43596836c842edc49df3e096e1d0833; six-file diff inspected, ten candidate rows counted, JSON parsed and count invariants checked. This is source-vetting only, not a package-security or behavioral pass.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Source vetting: reconcile ten official Product Design plugin skills without admission

1 participant