Error for for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { } doesn't provide enough context

Playpen

use std::collections::HashMap;

fn main() {
    for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
}

.cloned() failing is normal since the iterator's items are (&K, &V) and .cloned() expects &T, but the number of errors is strange.

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:36
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>                                    ^^^^^^

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`
note: required by `std::iter::IntoIterator::into_iter`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`
note: required by `std::iter::IntoIterator::into_iter`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::IntoIterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`
note: required by `std::iter::Iterator::next`

error: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`:
 expected tuple,
    found &-ptr [--explain E0271]
 --> <anon>:4:5
4 |>     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |>     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

error: aborting due to 9 previous errors

I also think the error should be improved.
Especially because you bluntly show user API that cannot be compiled.
I'm ofc talking about HashMap's iter docs

Current output:

error[E0271]: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`
 --> src/main.rs:4:36
  |
4 |     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |                                    ^^^^^^ expected tuple, found reference
  |
  = note: expected type `(&_, &_)`
             found type `&_`

error[E0271]: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`
 --> src/main.rs:4:14
  |
4 |     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |              ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ expected tuple, found reference
  |
  = note: expected type `(&_, &_)`
             found type `&_`
  = note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

There are two problems here that can be tackled independently:

The duplicated E0271 type mismatch errors can be fixed by modifying report_projection_error to not emit the diagnostic immediately, but rather to modify InferCtxt to keep a hashset of (expected_type, found_type, Span) so that the same error isn't emitted multiple times. All the duplicated errors (from the second onwards) seem to be caused by the implicit handling of iterators. Bonus points for collecting all the obligations and emitting them all together in the same diagnostic, instead of just losing the latter ones (requires either finding a method that gets called always at the end, or adding one). Done.
The error itself is not very illuminating and should have extra information provided in order to be helpful. For the case in particular of hash_map::Iter, it would be great if we could suggest the following, as that would actually do what the user expects (other than a missing type definition for the HashMap, on real code the HashMap would have been created before so that it would have had a chance to be populated), but I don't know how we could accomplish that in a clean way:

 --> src/main.rs:4:5
  |
4 |     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |     ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^-------^^^^^^^^^^^^^ expected tuple, found reference
  |                             |
  |                             help: did you mean to use `values()` here?

In general, it would probably be nice to have something along the lines of the following output on cases where type errors are propagated down a method call chain, but it's non-trivial to do and would still add little help here, so it should be out of scope of this issue:

error[E0271]: type mismatch resolving `<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _> as std::iter::Iterator>::Item == &_`
 --> src/main.rs:4:5
  |
4 |     for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }
  |     ^^^^^^^^^--------------^------^--------^^^^ expected tuple, found reference
  |              |              |      |
  |              |              |      found `&_` here
  |              |              found `std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>` here
  |              found `std::collections::HashMap<_, _>` here
  |
  = note: expected type `(&_, &_)`
             found type `&_`
  = note: required because of the requirements on the impl of `std::iter::Iterator` for `std::iter::Cloned<std::collections::hash_map::Iter<'_, _, _>>`

deduplicate projection error (E0271) messages

Rollup merge of rust-lang#45952 - zackmdavis:singular_projection, r=e…

Triage: no change.

I wonder is there handy utils to convert (&K, &V) into (K, V) without writing a closure?

Print type of every call in a method call chain

Rollup merge of rust-lang#105674 - estebank:iterator-chains, r=oli-obk

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

Error for `for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }` doesn't provide enough context #33941

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Error for for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { } doesn't provide enough context #33941

Description

Activity

DoumanAsh commented on May 29, 2016

estebank commented on Sep 30, 2017

estebank commented on Jan 22, 2020

yihuang commented on Jun 14, 2020

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions

Error for `for _ in HashMap::new().iter().cloned() { }` doesn't provide enough context #33941