You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Add message icon to rows that do contain a memo #2888
Thanks for opening this issue.
Actually we had just done something recently in that regard! #2865
Where it would say now, shielded memo and the amount would be a different color.
There will be a subsequent PR with a icon change, so we will leave this issue open as part of the discussion to a potential icon to represent a shielded memo that we can use.
I don't think that using different color is intuitive type of a UI, because you need to know about it, like to read the instruction "if a color is X then it means you have memo", while using some "now days" UI "industry standard" where the user can quickly tell, "oh there is some message inside" by looking at the icon.
The demo I used was just quick grab from google pics, so it's not the icon I desire, but just to show that having "message indicator" style icon is easy to discover and understand, the user would likely click/tap on the icon, and normal row popup would occur with all the details and 90% chance he would look at the bottom to notice memo text and from now on the user intuitively discovered the fact that "icon means memo is there + tap on the row to see it" and having approach with different row color doesn't do that, it would be more like "why is this row a different color?"
The current idea is, with the color it would make you re-read said transaction text which then would indicate by saying “received shielded memo” but yes an icon is still absolutely needed and necessary but the icons I had proposed fell semi flat from “generics”. It will still make enough for a user to understand and differentiate
Activity
Liquid369 commentedon Oct 11, 2023
Thanks for opening this issue.
Actually we had just done something recently in that regard!
#2865
Where it would say now, shielded memo and the amount would be a different color.
There will be a subsequent PR with a icon change, so we will leave this issue open as part of the discussion to a potential icon to represent a shielded memo that we can use.
skironDotNet commentedon Oct 11, 2023
I don't think that using different color is intuitive type of a UI, because you need to know about it, like to read the instruction "if a color is X then it means you have memo", while using some "now days" UI "industry standard" where the user can quickly tell, "oh there is some message inside" by looking at the icon.
The demo I used was just quick grab from google pics, so it's not the icon I desire, but just to show that having "message indicator" style icon is easy to discover and understand, the user would likely click/tap on the icon, and normal row popup would occur with all the details and 90% chance he would look at the bottom to notice memo text and from now on the user intuitively discovered the fact that "icon means memo is there + tap on the row to see it" and having approach with different row color doesn't do that, it would be more like "why is this row a different color?"
Liquid369 commentedon Oct 11, 2023
The current idea is, with the color it would make you re-read said transaction text which then would indicate by saying “received shielded memo” but yes an icon is still absolutely needed and necessary but the icons I had proposed fell semi flat from “generics”. It will still make enough for a user to understand and differentiate