Skip to content

docs(parity): decidiq's capability matrix, 193 rows against five competitors - #1372

Merged
rubenvdlinde merged 2 commits into
developmentfrom
parity/capability-matrix
Sep 25, 2026
Merged

rubenvdlinde merged 2 commits into
developmentfrom
parity/capability-matrix

Conversation

@rubenvdlinde

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Adds openspec/parity/capabilities.json, decidiq's capability matrix. This is a data file only. No page is wired to it, and nothing under openspec/ is loaded by the PHP or JS suites, so I did not run them.

Base: development at b7c056e. The workspace checkout's local development branch was a month stale (bacbcd0, 2026-08-31). I caught it by comparing against git ls-remote, then fetched the real tip before reading anything.

Up front: the live meeting page has no way in

/meetings/:id/live (src/manifest.json:720, src/views/LiveMeeting.vue) has no link anywhere in src/. You can only reach it by typing the URL. All four code readers hit this independently. It limits rows in the agenda, live, minutes and insight areas: time slots, quorum, speaker log, live decisions, meeting cost and efficiency. Those rows are rated partial with this reason, and the reason is stated once here rather than four times.

Category (step zero)

Decidiq competes as a meeting and decision-management system for governance bodies: it prepares and runs the meetings of a council, board, committee or members' assembly (agenda, papers, motions and amendments, voting including proxies, minutes, decision records and their follow-up) and publishes the outcome. Its deepest fit, going by the code, is the Dutch municipal council and its griffie, which buys a raadsinformatiesysteem (NotuBiz, iBabs, GO.); the same core also serves association general meetings, works councils and company boards, where the comparison is a board portal (Diligent) or an assembly tool (OpenSlides). Citizen participation ships as a module, but it is not what a buyer selects decidiq for. Written by the parity-new cold start on 2026-09-25; correct it here if it is wrong, since the areas, rows and columns all follow from it.

It is written into the file's category field so it can be corrected cheaply there.

Columns and why

column why readOn grade
NotuBiz Dutch council-information market leader (about 55 to 60% of municipalities) 2026-04-18 docs-only
iBabs second in that market (about 20 to 25%) and also sold as a board portal 2026-04-18 docs-only
GO. Raadsinformatie third in that market (about 15%) 2026-04-10 docs-only
Diligent Boards the board-portal comparison for company and association boards 2026-04-10 docs-only
OpenSlides the open-source assembly and voting tool, the one a members' assembly compares against 2026-04-10 docs-only

Why the other 170 of the 175 linked competitors stay out:

  • Most are a different category: AI note-takers (Otter, Fireflies, tl;dv and others), polling and survey tools, schedulers, e-signature vendors, whiteboards.
  • About 20 are plainly mis-tagged helpdesk and public-report tools (Odoo Helpdesk, FixMyStreet, Signalen, a Correos shipping integration, an AI chatbot).
  • Citizen-participation platforms (Decidim, CONSUL and others) are out because participation is decidiq's secondary module and not what a buyer selects it for. Decidim is the first column to add if that changes.
  • Smaller Dutch council-information vendors (Parlaeus, Notubiz Plus, Raadstaf and others) have only generic rows in the database.

The research, and what the database actually held

  • There is no concurrentie-analyse/decidesk/ or decidiq/ directory. Research does exist in two other places:
    • concurrentie-analyse/raadsinformatie/README.md (2026-03-27): a market study of NotuBiz, iBabs, GO. and Parlaeus, with tender requirements.
    • concurrentie-analyse/context/decidesk_*_context.md (March to April 2026).
  • competitor_apps joins 175 competitors to decidesk (174 direct, 1 medium).
  • competitor_features has 0 rows tagged decidesk. The 5,624 rows belonging to those competitors carry app_slug NULL, plus 3 tagged shillinq and 1 tagged docudesk.
  • Tagging traps:
    • A five-row block (SSO, 2FA, GDPR, webhooks, custom integrations) with identical text sits on 142 competitors. It is boilerplate and was not used as evidence.
    • Most of OpenSlides' 109 rows are release notes.
  • canonical_features holds 8,439 rows for decidesk, but 6,760 are category other. A sample is dominated by sentence fragments taken from papers ("algebra problems", "3d and 4d seismic surveys"). It is not usable as a feature list.
  • Every competitor cell is therefore docs-only, cites a competitor_features id or the README section, and its readOn is the capture date. Every unknown is covered by a one-sentence unknownReason on its system.

Shape

  • 193 rated rows and 7 pending, in 13 areas (10 to 19 rows each).
  • Own column: yes 55, partial 83, no 55.
  • built.state: built 75, building 83, specified 6, none 27, decided-no 2.

Where the rows came from:

  • 154 rated rows from decidiq's own code and 39 from what competitors do. Of the pending rows, 3 came from our code and 4 from competitors.
  • On the 39 competitor-derived rows decidiq reads no 25, partial 11, yes 3. That is the pattern the method predicts: rows drawn from our own code rate us well by construction.

built.owner:

owner rows
ConductionNL/decidiq 168
ConductionNL/openregister 9
ConductionNL/integriq 4
nextcloud/spreed 4
nextcloud/server 4
ConductionNL/filinq 1
ConductionNL/opencatalogi 1
ConductionNL/portaliq 1
ConductionNL/thematiq 1

Competitor cells rated (the rest are unknown):

system yes partial no
NotuBiz 30 5 3
iBabs 36 1 1
GO. 23 2 1
Diligent 21 8 1
OpenSlides 36 3 0

Verify

python3 .claude/skills/parity-verify/parity_verify.py openspec/parity/capabilities.json (hydra development), exit 0:

parity-verify: openspec/parity/capabilities.json
  193 rated rows, 7 pending, 6 systems

stale-reading  (5)
    system 'notubiz' was last read 2026-04-18 (160 days ago); a rating is a reading of one tree at one moment
    system 'ibabs' was last read 2026-04-18 (160 days ago); a rating is a reading of one tree at one moment
    system 'go-raadsinformatie' was last read 2026-04-10 (168 days ago); a rating is a reading of one tree at one moment
    system 'diligent-boards' was last read 2026-04-10 (168 days ago); a rating is a reading of one tree at one moment
    system 'openslides' was last read 2026-04-10 (168 days ago); a rating is a reading of one tree at one moment

unknown-cells  (1)
    831 cells rate unknown. That is legitimate, and it is listed so it cannot hide: capabilities[bod-01] go-raadsinformatie, capabilities[bod-01] diligent-boards, capabilities[bod-02] notubiz, capabilities[bod-02] ibabs, capabilities[bod-02] go-raadsinformatie, capabilities[bod-02] diligent-boards, capabilities[bod-03] notubiz, capabilities[bod-03] ibabs

6 finding(s) in 2 check(s)
report-only: pass --strict to fail on these

Strict profile: system-without-grade 0, grade-not-in-enum 0, cell-without-evidence 0, own-rating-without-evidence 0, unknown-without-reason 0. The tool prints a check only when it has findings, so none of these appear above. stale-reading on all five research-dated columns is the truth: nobody has driven these products.

Ten sample rows

id capability decidiq owner competitors (non-unknown)
vot-04 Hold a secret ballot. yes (built) ConductionNL/decidiq openslides yes
vot-10 Let a member authorise another member to vote on their behalf. partial (building) ConductionNL/decidiq all unknown
min-05 Sign approved minutes with a qualified electronic signature. partial (building) ConductionNL/integriq ibabs partial
min-13 Keep a tamper-evident record of every change to a decision and check it has not been altered. partial (building) ConductionNL/openregister openslides partial
pub-03 Offer council data through the Open Raadsinformatie API. yes (built) ConductionNL/decidiq notubiz yes, go-raadsinformatie yes
pub-05 Publish documents under the Woo categories and deliver them to the national Woo index. no (decided-no) ConductionNL/integriq notubiz yes, go-raadsinformatie yes
liv-01 Run a meeting from a live view that shows the chair and members the current item. partial (building) ConductionNL/decidiq openslides yes
liv-06 Stream the meeting live to the public. no (none) ConductionNL/decidiq notubiz yes, ibabs yes, go-raadsinformatie yes
rou-01 Send a proposal along a route of named people who must approve it before it goes to the body. partial (building) ConductionNL/decidiq notubiz yes, ibabs yes, diligent-boards partial
age-09 Mark an agenda item as confidential so only authorised people see its papers. partial (building) ConductionNL/decidiq notubiz yes, ibabs yes

Claimed differentiators nobody has checked (27)

These are the rows where decidiq reads yes and every competitor reads unknown. The research never mentioned them, so they are not verified advantages. They are the next pass's scope, and several are probably table stakes that no brochure bothers to list (such as recurring meetings or a personal task list).

  • bod-03 Import the members of a body from an existing Nextcloud group instead of typing them in.
  • bod-04 Define the positions in a body, such as chair, secretary or treasurer, and record who holds each one.
  • pla-03 Create a recurring series of meetings in one step.
  • pla-07 Keep a long-term agenda of topics planned for future meetings.
  • liv-14 Delete recordings and transcripts automatically after a retention period.
  • mot-06 Work out the order in which amendments are voted on.
  • vot-08 Choose the majority rule per vote, such as simple, absolute, two-thirds or unanimous.
  • min-04 Submit draft minutes for approval, collect corrections, and have them approved.
  • min-11 Withdraw or replace an earlier decision and keep the two linked.
  • fol-03 See all my own open action items across meetings.
  • fol-08 Flag action items that are past their due date.
  • rou-04 See the approval route and where it stands on the document itself.
  • rou-05 Record which body or official holds which delegated powers.
  • rou-13 Let another app start a decision and read back its outcome.
  • pub-04 Push voting results to an external Open Raadsinformatie endpoint when a vote closes.
  • par-03 Moderate citizen reactions before they are published.
  • par-04 Publish the outcome of a consultation.
  • par-05 Run a participatory budget round in which citizens propose projects.
  • par-06 Let citizens vote on the projects in a budget round.
  • par-07 Set up a citizen panel with fixed members and a term.
  • ins-03 Report on voting and attendance.
  • ins-07 See how efficiently meetings run, such as time spent per item.
  • ins-14 Record the audit committee's statement on the accounts.
  • plt-14 See on one admin page which integrations work and which do not.
  • plt-15 Apply the organisation's house style or NL Design System theme.
  • plt-16 Follow changes to meetings and decisions in the Nextcloud activity stream.
  • plt-17 Find meetings and decisions from the Nextcloud search bar.

Rows to revisit (not rewritten in this PR)

The readers flagged these:

  • liv-04 and vot-14 duplicate each other (a projected screen versus a live count on a screen).
  • mot-14 (anonymising a motion before publication) belongs in the publication area.
  • pla-05 (invitation with the agenda) overlaps age-05 (publishing the agenda).
  • min-09 bundles three things: legal basis, how to object, and effective date. It should probably be split.
  • bod-03 rates the import as working, but it is admin-only, so a secretary without admin rights cannot use it. The row may need an actor.
  • min-14: the proof package omits the minutes text and signatures. Decide whether the row promises those.
  • pen-03 overlaps bod-05 and bod-09.

Pending (7)

  • age-08, par-10 and plt-18 rest on declarations or sibling execution that this repo cannot prove (BOB phase property, portaliq executing the public-create declaration, OpenRegister delivering the outcome notification).
  • plt-05 (use on a phone) needs driving.
  • Three research questions:
    • pen-01: ISO 27001 hosting.
    • pen-02: control of the room's microphones and cameras.
    • pen-03: a public register of outside positions.

Inherited findings

None: this PR adds one JSON file under openspec/.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Work in progress: competitor cells from the research on record, decidiq's own
column not yet read from code.
193 rated rows and 7 pending across 13 areas, five competitor columns from
the research on record, graded docs-only and dated to that research.
@rubenvdlinde
rubenvdlinde merged commit 56fca2c into development Sep 25, 2026
36 checks passed
@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Quality Report — ConductionNL/decidiq @ 8b3729e

Check PHP Vue Security License Tests
lint ✅
phpcs ✅
phpmd ✅
psalm ✅
phpstan ✅
phpmetrics ✅
eslint ✅
stylelint ✅
build ✅
check-manifest ✅
check-nav-ceiling ✅
test-l10n ✅
format ✅
check-l10n-js ✅
check-schema-l10n ✅
composer ✅ ✅ 104/104
npm ✅ ✅ 652/652
app:check-code ⏭️
info.xml ✅
REUSE ❌
lockfile sync ✅
PHPUnit ⏭️ not run for this diff — no file in this diff matches the code globs, and none carries a source extension — the heavy tier has nothing to decide about it.
Newman ✅
Playwright ⏭️ deferred: E2E runs locally and on the promotion path only. This pull request targets development, so the suite is asked once per promotion into beta and main rather than once per push per open pull request. Run it on any branch from the Actions tab, or locally with npx playwright test.
Hydra gates ✅

Quality workflow — 2026-09-25 18:10 UTC

Download the full PDF report from the workflow artifacts.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant