Repository navigation
Description
Design and MVP issue, 1 November 2026, under #193. One public page per AI curator ("Inspired by Voltaire", later Hitchens and the rest) and a directory of them, answering four reader questions: which personalities are we using, what did we give each one, what has it actually done on the site, and what did that cost. It implements the profile-page part of #203 (closed on 21 October with "the specification here stands"), whose four-layer disclosure rule is kept verbatim in §3. It is a read-only projection of records that already exist; it adds no store, no model call and no change to how anything is published. It is not a prerequisite for #298 and must not be deployed inside one of #298's frozen windows.
1. Outcome
A reader who meets "Inspired by Voltaire · voltaire-whole-entry-v6 · qwen3.5-9b-whole-voltaire-v6" on a receipt can click it and land on a page that says, in plain words and then in inspectable detail: who this curator is modelled on and what we took from that person's work; what model runs it and with what settings; what instruction it follows; every version it has had and when the owner admitted each; every page it has published, assessed, abstained on or been refused on; what those calls cost; and what it is not (not the person, not their voice, not a fact-checker). The owner gets the same page as the single place to check an agent before admitting a new version.
2. What exists today (verified read-only on the Studio, 1 November 2026)
| Need | Already stored | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and status | curator_profiles: slug, label ("Inspired by Voltaire"), subject_label, state (proposed for bierce, vonnegut, hitchens, le-guin; admitted for voltaire and generic-editor), kind (persona or generic_editor), bot_actor_id, admitted_at, admission_reason, current_version_id |
profiles 1–5 and 16 |
| Dossier, per immutable version | curator_profile_versions: version, template_version (the instruction name), dossier JSON (disclosure, selection, principles, blind_spots, positive_example, negative_example), source_refs (work, edition, url, locators, rights, basis, exact permitted passages with speaker), deceased_evidence_refs (BnF authority record), change_reason, created_by_actor_id, manifest_hash |
7 Voltaire versions, 1 generic |
| Model binding | local_model_configs: model name, artifact manifest and weights digests, parameter size, quantization, runtime and version, generation settings (seed, temperature, context, output), licence, instruction_version, config_hash; curation_configuration_versions.manifest["editor"] ties profile version, bot actor and model config; curation_configuration_activations dates each binding |
configs 1–7, configuration versions 1–8 |
| The bot principal | one sources row of kind bot per binding (7 today) and one actors row with bot_source_id; the receipt's chooser line is that actor's label |
sources 7720, 7925…10873; actors 19, 22–25 |
| What it did | inference_attempts (purpose, outcome, packet hash, metrics, budget day) per model config; editorial_composition_versions with attempt_id and origin: model; editorial_composition_publications with authority_kind: single_editor and the bot actor_id; public receipts at /on/:slug/receipt/:version |
45 attempts; 26 model versions on 9 pages, 195 items; 26 single-editor publications |
| Cost | inference_ledger_entries (reserve, release, charge per day) and attempt metrics (wall ms, prompt and output tokens, memory, swap) |
per config: v6 10 calls, 102,845 ms, 26,571 prompt and 4,498 output tokens |
| Subject link | Ambrose Bierce exists as entity 1 with a public page at /people/ambrose-bierce; Voltaire, Vonnegut, Hitchens and Le Guin have no entity row yet |
/people/voltaire is 404 |
What is wrong today: each bot source renders through the generic source page (/sources/curator-voltaire-qwen3.5-9b-whole-voltaire-v6), which shows tiers, holdings and runs that are all zero and says nothing about the agent; the six Voltaire bindings and the generic editor are listed in the Sources directory between Bing News and GIPHY as if they were providers; receipts name the chooser in text but link nowhere. Nothing joins the profile, its versions, its bindings and its results on one page.
3. What the page says, and the record behind each part
The four layers are #203's and stay distinguishable on the page: inherited model knowledge, the dossier we wrote, the instruction and context actually supplied, the recorded result. Satire, exact sourced quotation, factual statement and generated commentary are labelled as such throughout.
- Header. Label, subject, status (proposed, admitted, retired), current version number and instruction, current model binding, "an AI selection lens inspired by …; not the person's voice or opinions" (the dossier's own
disclosuretext). Links: the subject's person page when one exists (Bierce today), otherwise the deceased-evidence authority record; the bot's receipts; the directory. - What we gave it: the dossier. Selection rule, principles, blind spots, one positive and one negative example, abstention rule, verbatim from the dossier JSON of the version shown. Sources: each work with edition, locators, rights note and the exact permitted passages, each marked with its speaker (for Voltaire: a fictional character, not the author). A sentence that the dossier is our interpretation, not a reconstruction of the person's beliefs.
- What runs it: the model. Model name and family, parameter size and quantization, artifact and weights digests, runtime and version, generation settings, licence, "no fine-tuning", and the model-card link if the owner adds one to the config row later. Labelled as pretrained knowledge we cannot enumerate.
- What it is told: the instruction. Instruction name and sha, the reviewed public summary of its rules (lead-first, evidence rules, section limits, abstention), packet policy (24 candidates, 12 meanings, sections), output contract. Not a raw prompt dump: the summary is a reviewed text per instruction version kept in the repository.
- What it did: the audit trail. A dated list, newest first, from attempts, versions and publications for every binding this profile ever had: page, date, outcome (published version n, assessed with no change, abstained, refused, deferred), attempt id, receipt link. Totals per binding: calls, accepted, abstained, refused, pages published, choices placed, choices later withheld by expiry. Owner interventions (holds, withdrawals) appear from the same records as what they are.
- What it cost. Per binding and in total: calls, inference wall time, prompt and output tokens, charged minutes of the daily budget, peak memory, swap. No money figures unless the owner records a rate.
- How it has been judged. Links to the dated scorecard reports in
docs/curation/evaluations/for experiments this profile took part in, with the headline counts (supported, insufficient, wrong, unsupported reasons) and the verdict, stated as developer judgments, not independent review. Empty for proposed profiles. - Versions. Every immutable version: number, instruction, date, who admitted it and why, hash, link to that version's page; which bindings and which published pages used it. Old receipts resolve to the version they used, never today's.
What else could go on this page, later (not MVP):
- consensus and dissent once a panel exists: ballots per candidate, agreement rate with other curators, where this lens differed and whether it carried (Curation agents: close out v6, retest v7, then controlled model and personality comparisons on identical packets (under #193) #298 D and Curation transparency: equal votes, reproducible selection, profiles and version history #203's policy);
- side-by-side with the generic control and with other models on matched cases, from Curation agents: close out v6, retest v7, then controlled model and personality comparisons on identical packets (under #193) #298's comparison report;
- what it withheld and why (policy-withheld reasons as counts, never text), and how often its choices later expired;
- the owner's edits to its selections (versions with
origin: operatorthat replaced a model version) as a visible correction rate; - human-readable diffs between dossier versions (Curation transparency: equal votes, reproducible selection, profiles and version history #203 §"Storage and reproducibility");
- a "retired" state with the reason and the last page it touched;
- an RSS or JSON feed of its publications, if readers want to follow one voice.
4. Wireframes
Directory, /curators (desktop):
┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ wordhoard Register Log in │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ The curators │
│ AI selection lenses that choose from the records a page already has. │
│ They never write definitions or quotations. Each is modelled on a │
│ deceased writer's work and labelled "inspired by"; none is that person. │
│ │
│ ACTIVE │
│ ┌──────────────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────────────┐ │
│ │ Inspired by Voltaire │ │ Generic editor │ │
│ │ v6 · qwen3.5 9B │ │ v1 · qwen3.5 9B │ │
│ │ 9 pages · 45 calls │ │ 0 pages · 4 calls │ │
│ │ admitted 1 Nov 2026 │ │ admitted 29 Oct 2026 │ │
│ └──────────────────────────┘ └──────────────────────────┘ │
│ PROPOSED (not yet used on any page) │
│ Inspired by Ambrose Bierce · Inspired by Kurt Vonnegut · │
│ Inspired by Christopher Hitchens · Inspired by Ursula K. Le Guin │
│ │
│ How curation works → /on/love/receipt/5 is an example receipt. │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Curator page, /curators/voltaire (desktop):
┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ ← The curators │
│ Inspired by Voltaire status: ADMITTED │
│ An AI selection lens inspired by Voltaire; not his voice or an │
│ assertion of his opinions about modern events. │
│ Subject: Voltaire (no entry on this site yet · BnF authority record ↗) │
│ Now: version 6 · voltaire-whole-entry-v6 · qwen3.5:9b Q4_K_M · since │
│ 1 Nov 2026 02:52 UTC │
├───────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ WHAT WE GAVE IT │ WHAT RUNS IT │
│ Selection rule (text) │ qwen3.5:9b · 9.7B · Q4_K_M · ollama 0.34.4 │
│ Principles (2) │ artifact 6488c96f… · weights dec52a44… │
│ Blind spots (1) │ seed 195 · temperature 0 · 8K ctx · 1,024 out│
│ Positive example │ Apache 2.0 · no fine-tuning │
│ Negative example │ Pretrained knowledge: not enumerable by us. │
│ Sources: Candide, Project │ │
│ Gutenberg 19942, 2 short │ WHAT IT IS TOLD │
│ passages (speakers: │ voltaire-whole-entry-v6 · sha e037baf1… │
│ Pangloss, Candide), │ lead first; sense definitions are leads; │
│ public domain in the USA │ titles alone are not evidence; 24 candidates │
│ Our interpretation, not │ 12 meanings; one call per page; abstain when │
│ his beliefs. │ nothing fits. Full summary → │
├───────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ WHAT IT DID totals: 45 calls · 9 pages │
│ 1 Nov 03:12 bestiality abstained attempt 45 │
│ 1 Nov 03:08 hope published v3 (7) attempt 44 · receipt → │
│ 1 Nov 03:08 truth published v3 (10) attempt 43 · receipt → │
│ … show all 45 → │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ WHAT IT COST v6: 10 calls · 1 m 43 s inference · 26,571 in / 4,498 out │
│ all bindings: 41 calls · 5 m 47 s · 0 swap │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ HOW IT HAS BEEN JUDGED │
│ 1 Nov 2026 v6 ten-page trial: 43 supported / 27 insufficient / 3 wrong │
│ of 73 choices; 20 unsupported reasons · NO-GO · developer judgment · │
│ report → │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ VERSIONS │
│ 6 voltaire-whole-entry-v6 1 Nov 2026 owner "frozen 72-hour trial" → │
│ 5 voltaire-whole-entry-v5 29 Oct owner "relevance-first" → │
│ … │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Phone (390 px): the same sections stacked in the order header, what it did (last five), what we gave it, what runs it, what it is told, cost, judged, versions; each section collapsed to its first line with a disclosure toggle; no horizontal scroll; tables become definition lists.
Version page, /curators/voltaire/v/5: the header says "version 5 of 6, superseded 1 Nov 2026"; the same dossier, sources and instruction blocks frozen at that version; "used by" lists bindings and published versions that cite it; links to previous and next.
5. MVP
Read-only LiveViews over existing tables; no migration unless a field is missing (none identified). No model call, no change to packets, publication, admission or the trial.
- M1. Routes (route conventions are Routing before launch: On overviews, standards-informed namespaces, and stable subject URLs #194's; proposal):
/curators(directory),/curators/:slug(current version),/curators/:slug/v/:n(immutable version). Bot source pages (/sources/curator-*and/sources/generic-editor) redirect to the profile page with the binding anchored, and bot sources leave the Sources directory list. Receipts link the chooser label to/curators/:slug/v/:n. - M2. Projection. One context function that assembles a profile page from
curator_profiles,curator_profile_versions,curation_configuration_versionsand activations,local_model_configs, botsourcesandactors,inference_attempts,editorial_composition_versions,editorial_composition_publicationsandinference_ledger_entries, keyed by every bot actor the profile ever had. Counts are computed, never stored. - M3. Reviewed instruction summaries. One short public text per instruction version under
priv/curation/agents/instructions/<name>.md, reviewed like code; the page shows it with the instruction sha. Never the raw system prompt, chain-of-thought or packet contents. - M4. The four layers and the labels. Every block carries its layer label and the sentence that applies (pretrained knowledge not enumerable; our interpretation; reviewed summary; recorded result not a causal trace). Proposed profiles say "not yet used on any page" and show no invented activity.
- M5. Privacy and retention. No provider payloads, no excerpts from expired observations, no prompt text, no private operational metadata, no email. Dossier passages render only where
source_refs.rightspermits; otherwise the reference and rights note. Withheld reasons show as counts. - M6. Subject link. Link to
/people/:slugwhen the subject has an entity; otherwise show "no entry on this site yet" and the deceased-evidence reference. Minting Voltaire's entity is Link the words their sources already identify: mint the 21,544 QIDs WordNet and Wiktionary name, run the identifier rungs lexicon-wide, and link on visit (after #172) #217's path, optional here. - M7. Tests. LiveView tests for directory, profile, version and redirect pages; a proposed profile, an admitted profile with several bindings, an expired choice counted as withheld; a check that no field of the page contains payload text from
source_record_revisions. Full precommit in an isolated partition; CodeRabbit; independent exact-head review. - M8. Deploy on the owner's yes, between Curation agents: close out v6, retest v7, then controlled model and personality comparisons on identical packets (under #193) #298 windows (never inside a frozen trial, which pins the serving SHA), by fast-forward; no config change expected, so no restart.
6. Not in this issue
Consensus display, ballots and dissent (no such records exist yet); dossier diffs; an owner UI for editing dossiers (they are reviewed JSON under priv/curation/agents/personas/); admitting any new persona (that is #298 and its migrations); public money figures; a general "agent framework"; changes to receipts beyond the chooser link.
7. Acceptance
- A reader can go receipt → curator page → exact version → dossier sources → subject page or authority record, and back to the pilot pages.
- The directory shows the real roster with truthful states; proposed profiles have no activity; retired bindings stay visible with dates.
- Every count on the page can be reproduced by a read-only query posted in the PR description (attempts, publications, items, cost per binding).
- Old receipts resolve to the version they cite after a newer version is admitted.
- No prompt text, chain-of-thought, provider payload or expired excerpt appears on any curator surface, proven by a test.
- Desktop and 390 px layouts checked; no horizontal overflow.
- Merged from an independently reviewed exact head with precommit counts; deployed between trial windows on the owner's yes.
8. Owner decisions
- CD-1, route names. Proposed
/curators; alternatives/editorsor/lenses. Routing before launch: On overviews, standards-informed namespaces, and stable subject URLs #194 owns the convention. - CD-2, bot sources in the Sources directory. Proposed: remove them from the provider list and redirect their pages; keep the rows (receipts and actors depend on them).
- CD-3, public cost figures. Proposed: show calls, time and tokens; no money.
- CD-4, Voltaire's entity. Proposed: not required for the MVP; mint later through Link the words their sources already identify: mint the 21,544 QIDs WordNet and Wiktionary name, run the identifier rungs lexicon-wide, and link on visit (after #172) #217's identifier path so the subject link appears.
Activity
holden commentedon Nov 1, 2026
Executor prompt for the MVP, M1–M7 (recorded 1 November 2026; can start now, in parallel with the running trial)
holden commentedon Nov 3, 2026
M1–M7 in a reviewable PR: #304 (head 6a2e219), not deployed
The curator pages MVP is in #304, on branch
claude/299-curator-pages, cut fromd33a655. Its head is6a2e2196a46f2fa01c843686c1308668bf89d8c7./curators,/curators/:slugand/curators/:slug/v/:n. They are a read-only projection over the existing tables, with no migration and noconfig/*.exsormix.lockchange.priv/curation/agents/instructions/, shown with the instruction's sha256./curators; bot sources out of the provider list; calls, time and tokens, no money; Voltaire's entity later via Link the words their sources already identify: mint the 21,544 QIDs WordNet and Wiktionary name, run the identifier rungs lexicon-wide, and link on visit (after #172) #217). The PR lists them for the owner to confirm.curator_live_test.exs. Fullmix precommitin partition_c299: 19 doctests, 3,344 tests, 0 failures at the head. The 390 px and 1280 px layouts were checked, with no horizontal overflow.coderabbit auth login, owner). The GitHub app reviews the PR.Deployment (M8) is the owner's. Deploy only between #298 windows, never inside a frozen trial, and only on the owner's yes, by fast-forward. No restart is expected. Merging it activates nothing: no panel, no persona admission and no change to the running trial. An independent exact-head review is being arranged separately.
#309 D3: the independent review's three REQUIRED items, and its cheap…