You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
💡 Holiday & Art Market Event Mode with Maker Show-Circuit Following
#540
Support one-off and multi-day markets (holiday makers' markets, juried art fairs, pop-ups) as first-class market types next to weekly farmers markets, and let shoppers follow a maker to see every upcoming show where they will appear. Markets is positioned for 'farmer and art markets', but every planned flow assumes a weekly produce market.
Market Signal
TheCraftMap lists 792 US holiday fairs in 2026, 511 of them in November. Events such as SJMADE Holiday Fair have 350+ makers, and Milwaukee Makers Market has 120+ artists. Craft-fair planning guides tell makers to post their show schedule on social media and send newsletters announcing where they will be, which is manual and fragmented. Incumbent tools for these events (Eventeny, Marketspread jurying, Jotform/Paperform applications) focus on organizer operations. They give shoppers no way to follow a maker across shows.
User Signal
README (#538, Nov 5 2026) now describes Markets as 'market-day coordination for local farmer and art markets'. The domain research identifies 'art/craft-focused markets' as a primary segment. Yet the only art-related artifact in the epics is a single 'Artisan' category chip in Story 6.0.
Technical Opportunity
MarketDay is already a core table, so a one-off event is a market with explicit dated MarketDays and no weekly rule. Story 3.3 (calendar date selection) already associates vendors with specific dates. The existing follow graph plus a 'vendor upcoming market days' query delivers 'see where this maker is next' without new infrastructure. Exception statuses need one art-specific preset ('booth location changed' or 'item sold' instead of 'sold out of tomatoes').
Assessment
Dimension
Score
Rationale
Feasibility
med
See Technical Opportunity
Impact
med
See Market & User Signal
Urgency
med
Epic 2/7 stories are still backlog — cheapest to shape now
Adversarial Review
Strongest objection: This dilutes focus. Pilots are farmers markets, the team is tiny, and art fairs are infrequent, so the weekly habit loop that drives retention does not exist there. Rebuttal: The data-model cost is small if decided now alongside the multi-season schedule work. The customer payoff (follow a maker and get notified when they join a show) reuses follow and notification code already planned. Art markets also matter for acquisition: a 350-maker holiday fair puts thousands of shoppers in one place who are actively looking for vendors, which makes it a strong install moment that feeds the weekly farmers-market loop. Keep jurying, ticketing and fees out of scope.
Suggested Next Step
Interview 3 organizers of holiday or art markets and 5 makers this November (peak season). Validate whether 'where will you be next' is a real shopper ask, and whether makers would maintain an upcoming-shows list in exchange for follower notifications. Record the decision on one-off market types in the story 2.2 revision.
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Summary
Support one-off and multi-day markets (holiday makers' markets, juried art fairs, pop-ups) as first-class market types next to weekly farmers markets, and let shoppers follow a maker to see every upcoming show where they will appear. Markets is positioned for 'farmer and art markets', but every planned flow assumes a weekly produce market.
Market Signal
TheCraftMap lists 792 US holiday fairs in 2026, 511 of them in November. Events such as SJMADE Holiday Fair have 350+ makers, and Milwaukee Makers Market has 120+ artists. Craft-fair planning guides tell makers to post their show schedule on social media and send newsletters announcing where they will be, which is manual and fragmented. Incumbent tools for these events (Eventeny, Marketspread jurying, Jotform/Paperform applications) focus on organizer operations. They give shoppers no way to follow a maker across shows.
User Signal
README (#538, Nov 5 2026) now describes Markets as 'market-day coordination for local farmer and art markets'. The domain research identifies 'art/craft-focused markets' as a primary segment. Yet the only art-related artifact in the epics is a single 'Artisan' category chip in Story 6.0.
Technical Opportunity
MarketDay is already a core table, so a one-off event is a market with explicit dated MarketDays and no weekly rule. Story 3.3 (calendar date selection) already associates vendors with specific dates. The existing follow graph plus a 'vendor upcoming market days' query delivers 'see where this maker is next' without new infrastructure. Exception statuses need one art-specific preset ('booth location changed' or 'item sold' instead of 'sold out of tomatoes').
Assessment
Adversarial Review
Strongest objection: This dilutes focus. Pilots are farmers markets, the team is tiny, and art fairs are infrequent, so the weekly habit loop that drives retention does not exist there.
Rebuttal: The data-model cost is small if decided now alongside the multi-season schedule work. The customer payoff (follow a maker and get notified when they join a show) reuses follow and notification code already planned. Art markets also matter for acquisition: a 350-maker holiday fair puts thousands of shoppers in one place who are actively looking for vendors, which makes it a strong install moment that feeds the weekly farmers-market loop. Keep jurying, ticketing and fees out of scope.
Suggested Next Step
Interview 3 organizers of holiday or art markets and 5 makers this November (peak season). Validate whether 'where will you be next' is a real shopper ask, and whether makers would maintain an upcoming-shows list in exchange for follower notifications. Record the decision on one-off market types in the story 2.2 revision.
Sources
Generated by the weekly feature-ideation run (Mary, BMAD Analyst).
All reactions